amateur still have his day?â
âThey will neither be required nor consulted, Watson. He is more likely I fear to be arrested for obstruction than listened to or heeded.â
ââThe Whole Art of Detectionâ could have been an important document, an account of your life with the emphasis where it should be; with your deductive skills to the fore instead of the sensationalist element I sometimes let slip into the stories of your doings.â
âSometimes? I am not convinced anyone would want to read such a dry document, all in all, the general populace seem happy to know me through your chronicles and do you know, I am more than happy with that.â
âI am surprised to hear you say it, Holmes. Could it be you have mellowed?â
âQuite possibly, my friend, quite possibly.â
âAt least you entered the published world through your monographs.â
âAh yes, my monographs. Dry as dust and no doubt just as un-readable. I donât believe I ever encountered anyone who had ever read the blessed things excepting your good self of course. You did read them, did you not?â
âWell, I certainly looked through them, I would hesitate to call it reading, but I believe I caught the gist of all the salient points you made.â
âYou never seemed to have any trouble reading your sea-faring tales ad infinitum.â
âThey were full-blooded and exciting, Holmes, whereas your monographs were-â
âYes, Watson?â
â-as dry as dust.â
âTouché, Watson, or perhaps I should say more rightly; Et tu Watson! And all this from a discussion of your perceived limitations as a writer!â
âEvery man has his limitations in all walks of life, perhaps they serve to cure us of the weakness of self-satisfaction.â
âI can see no harm in self-satisfaction, indeed I see more harm in not being satisfied enough. We should all strive to attain the utmost reward for our talents.â
âBut that in no way negates self-satisfaction being an ill. It surely is the self-satisfied man who will never strive and reach out for further achievement.â
âAh, but if he reaches the pinnacle of those achievements, then he can be well and truly self-satisfied.â
âItâs a question of degrees then?â
âPrecisely so. You say your limitations as a writer served to cure you of the weakness of self-satisfaction?â
âWhy, yes.â
âIn other words, then, you were not satisfied and wanted to extend your literary skills?â
âNo, I was happy not to seek to extend myself in that direction.â
âFrom your own mouth then, you proclaim yourself to be self-satisfied and your limitations did nothing to cure you of it. A point for me, Watson?â
âYes, Holmes, I believe you are taking advantage of my weary state.â
âFar from it, I never did get your limits and exploring them now is of the greatest interest to me. A case in point is your account of the Enoch Drebber murder in the case you called âA Study in Scarletâ. They were described on the frontispiece as being a reprint from your reminiscences, but nothing else ever followed concerning your life. Why not?â
âItâs simple, Holmes. I found your life to be a far more interesting one than my own. The readers wanted to know about you, not me.â
âPerhaps they may have been eager for tales of your experience of women, which extended over many nations and three separate continents, unless your prowess in those matters was somewhat overstated.â
âMy natural discretion would naturally not allow me to compile such an account.â
âGood old Watson!â
âAs you were so fond of saying, the fair sex was my department.â
âYour natural charm carried all before you; I was constantly bewildered by the ease with which you relaxed in womenâs company. I do not mean that unkindly, you